Unless you've been in a cave or on a desserted island for the last few months, you can't help but notice every store in town has Halloween goodies shoved right up at the entrance. Crates filled with bags of candy, racks full of costumes, and aisles filled with make-up, wigs, hats, and all sorts of other accessories.
I had to walk past all this junk today at the store, and it's already come up in conversation a few times, so I wanted to take a few minutes to write about a particular aspect of this. I hope you'll indulge me and consider what I'm saying.
For me, there have been various phases of halloween.
Phase 1A
Like most people in my generation, I grew up in what was considered a culturally Christian community. Pretty much everyone went to church on Sunday morning whether they wanted to or not. Going to church did not mean you were a Christian, although if asked, you'd say that you were (because you went to church).
Every year on Halloween you'd dress up in your favorite cartoon character and grab ye old pillow case from the linen closet and off you'd go. There were certain houses you weren't allowed to go to:
a.) the ones with the porch light off
b.) the ones with the dog out in the yard
There were also rules about the candy you got:
a.) no eating of any candy until you got home and mom checked it out
b.) no eating of any unwrapped candy - ever
c.) no eating of any popcorn balls unless mom knew the neighbor that they came from
You trick or treated until the inside of your plastic mask was stinky with your own breath, and/or the thin white elastic band finally gave way on one side and you had to hold your mask on. By the time these events would occur, you knew it was just a matter of time before your mom was going to say "okay kids, I think we've been out here long enough". The dreaded and doomed words of adult logic crashing down on the ears of greedy candy mongers scouring the streets for more and more.
Phase 1B
As you grew up, the cheap plastic masks were replaced with the cool latex ones, or your own handy work from cheap clothes & props from the second hand store. You hoped no one would notice that you were "too old!" to go trick or treating, and in some ways you really felt like you were, but didn't want to admit it to anyone, especially yourself. As the years ticked by you no longer trick or treated, but you still dressed up (like a complete fool) and either went to parties (with an abundance of fools) or held them in your own home. Gone were the pillow cases stuffed with miniture Hershey bars (which were a lot bigger when I was a kid!) and orange colored popcorn balls, those were now just a faded memory of childhood. Such items were now replaced with more adult-style treats and beverages, and the odd thing was, the more you imbibed in them, the more you acted like a 5 year old child. Go figure.
Millions of Americans and Canadians my age, are still in Phase 1B of North American Halloween. It is inarguably one of the most consumer driven "holidays" of the year, and has been this way for a very long time. You know this to be true and probably thought about it even briefly yourself, as you passed the huge boxes of JuJubes and Junior Mints at the grocery store, back in JULY.
For a lot of Christians though, Halloween takes on some new phases.
For us, there were at least 3 more:
Phase 2 - The Waffler Stage
After conversion, there was the pesky issue of Halloween to deal with. In 1994 (and for several years prior to that) our house was THE neighborhood Halloween house. I don't say that to boast, just to state facts. There is nothing to boast in, in this account, other than we were dolts.
We had spent many years fine tuning our Phase 1B'ness, and we'd figured out how to really deck the outside of the house to creep out the toughest of the tough. Sound affects, animated hanging things, and more. By 1993, we'd nearly perfected a lifesize dummy (complete with liquid latex face mask of a real person, and latex arms and legs for a very realistic affect). "Bob" as he became known, spent the year in the woodshed and every October first he'd be brought out, cleaned up, and put on display. Bob was animated with fishing line - and could stand, sit, turn, wave, and do just about anything you can do with a hand held marionette. Only Bob was lifesized and operated through the window, on large slats of wood attached to the line. Bob was creepy, but people were drawn to him like mad. Rather demented, actually.
In any case... new life in Christ came in the spring of 1994, so by the fall we had some issues to deal with. What to do about Bob? What to do about costumes, dressing up, and all that comes with that? We weren't really sure, so we did what we always did, (because tradition is comforting that way) and before the night was even half over, we felt heartsick, and weren't even having fun. We didn't even need to talk about it, we all knew what was happening. So, we decided on November 1st, that Bob had officially retired and would not be back the following year. We'd trade in our ghoulish spook-duds for happy/frilly/silly/funny costumes and everything would be okay. We were only kidding ourselves, and we knew it, but we played along for about 6 months.
Ben was getting really sick, and finally had to go to the hospital for care. One of the days he was lucid, we finally had a real conversation about Halloween. He said something to the affect of "you know we're just compromising, right?". I said yes, that I did. So I asked, "what do you think about just NOT participating at all this year?". I honestly didn't even think he'd be there for halloween that year, but he said "I think we should have made that decision a year ago". So it was settled, we wouldn't celebrate it that year.
Ben passed away 2 months before Halloween, and our decision to opt out, was replaced with me caving in to pressure to conform. I hated that I did it, but I did it all the same. The girls were glad to go out, but they knew it was the last time, ever.
Phase 3 - The Rabid Legalist Stage
The following year was filled with researching the origins and traditions associated with halloween. I read everything I could get my hands on, went to the library, borrowed books, watched tapes, and more. I even went so far as to begin interviewing Wiccans online, to get their perspective on Christians that celebrate halloween, and where some of our modern day traditions come from. That was a real eye opener, to be sure.
More than ever, I was convinced that not only was it wrong for me and my family to participate, it was wrong for any Christian to participate, and it was my job to tell them all about it. Yep, I fell into the trap, and I fell hard. For the next couple of years I was in the Rabid Legalist Stage, and it got ugly. Real ugly.
By this time Kev and I were married and he was my partner in Rabid Legalist Stage Crime. He was as bad (or worse?) as I was, and together we were just pathetic. We were those people that you might see charicatured as saying "our little ones will NEVER know what this trick or treating is all about!" in a real smug way that gives the impression that OUR kids are going to be the better for it, so pooh-pooh on you, you heathen. Yes, we even plastered the grocery stores with Chick tracts to warn the masses just how evil halloween really is.
Well, while our youngest four kids have never participated in any kind of halloween event, that has more to do with the fact that the Lord saw fit to knock us down a few pegs and cause us to see how ridiculous we were actually being about the whole thing. While our convictions to remain disassociated from the whole thing were genuine, the way we'd gone about it was all very grace-less and unkind, at times. Rabid Legalist Stage came to a crashing halt, about 5 years ago.
Phase 4 - Quietly Contented Stage
We learned the hard way that while we may be convicted of something, that doesn't mean that others have been, and trying to force our convictions on them will never work. It was embarassing, but it was a lesson we both needed to learn.
We both came to a place where IF asked, we would tell people why we do not participate in halloween. Pretty simple.
However, over the last few years we've both noticed something really strange.
As Rabidly Legalistic as we used to be against halloween, we've both encountered Christians that are almost as rabidly PRO halloween, and try to make us (or anyone else that has opted out) feel like we're depriving our kids or something if we don't join in. It's a most awkward kind of situation - and you can bet you're going to see plenty of examples of this in the weeks to come, on blogs, message forums, etc. I see more and more of it every year.
Brothers and sisters actually made fun of, mocked, and belittled, because they don't celebrate Halloween.
This ought not take place among the household of faith, but it sure does.
It seems to me, having been on both sides of this issue, that the truly Christian thing to do is follow your convictions, and respect those who differ from you, at this time (wherever you happen to be with this issue, yourself).
Of course dressing up is fun - who doesn't like to do that?
Of course candy is fun - we all like candy! Don't we?
The thing is, it's not about those things at all. If you're someone who has been convicted to opt out, then follow His lead and if others ask why, tell them with gentleness and grace. If you're someone who participates, then participate and don't take issue with those who don't - they've been led a different direction and that should be respected.
Just some nutritional food for thought, as the season of halloween candy is already upon us.
And with that, I will be back sometime Sunday night. Have a great weekend, and a blessed Lord's Day.
Related Tags: sovereign grace, baptist, the 5 solas, Christian homeschooling, Christian t-shirts and gifts